defirisk.co
rubric v1.7.0

Factor encyclopedia

184 evidence factors across 13 categories. Click any factor for methodology, measurement, and which protocols carry it.

184 factors 13 categories 20 critical rubric v1.7.0
Category
Severity
ID Factor Category Carried
RD-F-001 Audit scope mismatch Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-002 Audit recency Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-003 Resolved-without-proof findings Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-004 Audit count Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-005 Audit firm tier Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-006 Audit-to-deploy gap Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-007 Bug bounty presence & max payout Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-008 Ignored bounty disclosure Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-009 Formal verification coverage Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-010 Static-analyzer high-severity count Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-011 SELFDESTRUCT reachable from non-admin path Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-012 delegatecall with user-controlled target Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-013 Arbitrary call with user-controlled target Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-014 Reentrancy guard on external-calling functions Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-015 ERC-777/1155/721 hook without reentrancy guard Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-016 Divide-before-multiply pattern Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-017 Mixed-decimals math without explicit scaling Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-018 Signed/unsigned arithmetic confusion Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-019 ecrecover zero-address return unchecked Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-020 EIP-712 domain separator missing chainId Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-021 UUPS _authorizeUpgrade correctly permissioned Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-022 Public initialize() without initializer modifier Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-023 Constructor calls _disableInitializers() Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-024 Code complexity vs audit coverage Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-025 Admin key custody type Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-026 Upgrade multisig signer configuration (M/N) Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-027 Single admin EOA Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-028 Low-threshold multisig vs TVL Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-029 Multisig signers co-hosted Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-030 Hot-wallet signer flag Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-031 Signer rotation recency Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-032 Timelock duration on upgrades Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-033 Timelock on sensitive actions Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-034 Guardian/pause-keeper distinct from upgrader Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-035 Role separation: upgrade ≠ fee ≠ oracle Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-036 Flash-loanable voting weight Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-037 Quorum achievable via single-entity flash loan Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-038 Proposal execution delay < 24h Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-039 delegatecall/call in proposal execution without allowlist Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-040 Emergency-veto multisig present Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-041 Rescue/emergencyWithdraw without timelock Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-042 Admin has mint() with unlimited max Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-043 Admin = deployer EOA after 7 days Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-044 Admin wallet interacts with flagged addresses Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-045 Constructor args match governance proposal Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-046 Contract unverified on Etherscan/Sourcify Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-047 Governance token concentration (Gini) Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-048 Oracle providers used Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-049 Oracle role per asset Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-050 Dependency graph (protocols depended upon) Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-051 Fallback behavior on oracle failure Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-052 Breakage analysis per dependency Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-053 Oracle source = spot DEX pool (no TWAP) Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-054 TWAP window duration Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-055 Oracle pool depth (USD) Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-056 Single-pool oracle (no medianization) Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-057 Circuit breaker on price deviation Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-058 Max-deviation threshold (bps) Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-059 Oracle staleness check present Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-060 Chainlink aggregator min/max bound misconfig Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-061 LP token balanceOf used for pricing Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-062 External keeper/relayer not redundant Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-063 TVL (current + 30d trend) Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-064 TVL concentration (top-10 wallet share) Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-065 Liquidity depth per major asset Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-066 Utilization rate (lending protocols) Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-067 Historical bad-debt events Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-068 Collateralization under stress Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-069 Algorithmic / under-collateralized stablecoin Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-070 Empty cToken-style market (zero supply/borrow) Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-071 Seed-deposit requirement for new market listing Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-072 Market-listing governance threshold Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-073 Oracle-manipulation-proof borrow cap Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-074 ERC-4626 virtual-share offset (OZ ≥4.9) Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-075 First-depositor / share-inflation guard Economic risk 0 of 0 RD-F-076 Protocol age (days) Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-077 Prior exploit count Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-078 Chronic-exploit flag (≥3 incidents) Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-079 Same-root-cause repeat exploit Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-080 Days since last exploit Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-081 Post-exploit response score Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-082 Post-mortem published within 30 days Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-083 Auditor re-engaged after last exploit Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-084 TVL stability (CoV over 90d) Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-085 Incident response time (minutes) Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-086 Pause activations (trailing 12 months) Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-087 Pause > 7 consecutive days Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-088 Re-deployed to new addresses in last year Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-089 Insurance coverage active Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-090 Mixer withdrawal → protocol interaction Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-091 Partial-drain test transactions Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-092 Unusual mempool pattern from deployer wallet Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-093 Abnormal gas-price willingness from attacker wallet Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-094 New contract with similar bytecode to exploit template Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-095 Known-exploit function-selector replay Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-096 New ERC-20 approval to unverified contract from whale Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-097 Sybil surge of identical-pattern transactions Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-098 TVL anomaly — % drop in <1h Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-099 Oracle price deviation >X% from secondary Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-100 Flash loan >$10M targeting protocol tokens Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-101 Large governance proposal queued Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-102 Admin/upgrade transaction in mempool Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-103 Bridge signer-set change proposed/executed Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-104 Stablecoin depeg >2% on shared-LP venue Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-105 DNS/CDN/frontend hash drift Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-106 Cross-chain bridge unverified mint pattern Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-107 Admin EOA signing from new geography/device Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-108 GitHub force-push to sensitive branch Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-109 Social-media impersonation scam spike Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-110 Unusual pending/executed proposal ratio Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-111 Team doxx status Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-112 Team public accountability surface Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-113 Team other-protocol involvement history Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-114 Deployer address prior on-chain history Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-115 Prior rug/exit-scam affiliation Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-116 Contributor tenure at admin-permissioned PR Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-117 ENS/NameStone identity bound to deployer Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-118 Handle reuse across failed/rugged projects Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-119 Commit timezone consistent with stated geography Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-120 Video-off/voice-consistency flag Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-121 Contributor OSINT depth score Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-122 Contributor paid to DPRK-cluster wallet Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-123 Sudden admin-rescue/ACL change without discussion Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-124 Deployer wallet mixer-funded within 30 days Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-125 Deployer linked within 3 hops to DPRK/Lazarus Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-126 Is-a-fork-of Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-127 Upstream patch not merged Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-128 Upstream vulnerability disclosure (last 90d) Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-129 Code divergence from upstream (%) Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-130 Fork depth (generations from original audit) Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-131 Fork retains upstream audit coverage Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-132 Fork has different economic parameters than upstream Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-133 Dependency manifest uses unpinned versions Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-134 Dependency had malicious-release incident (last 90d) Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-135 Shared-library version with known-vuln status Fork / dependency lineage 0 of 0 RD-F-136 Deployed bytecode matches signed release tag Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-137 Upgrade frequency (per 90 days) Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-138 Hot-patch deploys without timelock (last 30 days) Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-139 Post-audit code changes without re-audit Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-140 Fix-merged-but-not-deployed gap Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-141 Test-mode parameters in deploy Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-142 Storage-layout collision risk across upgrades Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-143 Reinitializable implementation (no _disableInitializers) Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-144 CREATE2 factory permits same-address redeploy Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-145 Deployed bytecode reproducibility Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-146 New contract deploys in last 30 days Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-147 Protocol has bridge surface Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-148 Bridge validator count (M) Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-149 Bridge validator threshold (k-of-M) Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-150 Bridge validator co-hosting Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-151 Bridge ecrecover checks result ≠ address(0) Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-152 Bridge binds message to srcChainId Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-153 Bridge tracks nonce-consumed mapping Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-154 Default bytes32(0) acceptable as valid root Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-155 Bridge validator-set rotation recency Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-156 Bridge uses same key custody for >30% validators Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-157 Bridge TVL per validator ratio Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-158 Known-threat-actor cluster has touched protocol Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-159 Attacker wallet pre-strike probe (low-gas failing txs) Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-160 GitHub malicious-dependency incident touching protocol deps Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-161 Protocol-impersonator domain registered (typosquat) Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-162 Known-exploit-template selector deployed by any address Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-163 Avg attacker reconnaissance time for peer-class protocols Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-164 Leaked credential on paste/sentry site Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-165 Protocol social channel has scam-coordinator flag Threat intelligence & recon 0 of 0 RD-F-166 Deprecated contracts still holding value Operational history 0 of 0 RD-F-167 Deprecated contract paused but pause reversible by live admin Governance & admin 0 of 0 RD-F-168 Stale-approval exposure on deprecated router Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0 RD-F-170 Solc version used (known-bug versions flagged) Tooling / compiler / AI 0 of 0 RD-F-171 Bytecode similarity to audited upstream with behavior deviation Tooling / compiler / AI 0 of 0 RD-F-172 Repo shows AI-tool co-authorship in critical files Tooling / compiler / AI 0 of 0 RD-F-173 Team self-disclosure of AI-generated Solidity Tooling / compiler / AI 0 of 0 RD-F-174 Dependency tree uses EOL Solidity version Tooling / compiler / AI 0 of 0 RD-F-175 Disclosure channel exists Response & disclosure hygiene 0 of 0 RD-F-176 Disclosure SLA public Response & disclosure hygiene 0 of 0 RD-F-177 Prior known-ignored disclosure Response & disclosure hygiene 0 of 0 RD-F-178 CVE/GHSA advisory issued against protocol Response & disclosure hygiene 0 of 0 RD-F-179 LayerZero OFT DVN config (count, threshold, diversity) Cross-chain & bridge 0 of 0 RD-F-180 Immutable oracle address Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-181 Permissionless-pool lending oracle Oracle & external dependencies 0 of 0 RD-F-182 Security-Council threshold reduction (RT) Real-time signals 0 of 0 RD-F-183 Bug bounty scope gap on highest-TVL contracts Code & audits 0 of 0 RD-F-184 Real-capital social-engineering persona Dev identity & insider risk 0 of 0 RD-F-185 Bridge rate-limiter / chain-pause as positive mitigant Post-deploy hygiene & change mgmt 0 of 0